Wednesday, November 11, 2009

In the Aftermath of Ft. Hood, Marking Veterans Day With a Message of Thanks

I have spent the past week immersed in the shootings at Ft. Hood, delving into the tragedy on behalf of a major national magazine. The book has gone to press, and soon will be on newsstands. I'm just now coming up for air - to find that it is Veterans Day. This year, so soon after the horrific events that took the lives of 12 soldiers, one civilian, and an unborn child, the holiday has special resonance. To mark the occasion, I am reposting an essay that conveys a universal message, not only to the Ft. Hood community, but also to all our veterans: A message of thanks.



Twenty-five-plus years ago, some Vietnam veterans tumbled into my newspaper office, urging me to write an “enormously important” story about a new memorial to American troops who died in Southeast Asia. The story was indeed important. But the Vietnam Veterans Memorial, slated for Washington, D.C., was a national story. It had no place on the pages of California’s weekly Dixon Tribune newspaper. I told the men I couldn't help them.



I expected an argument. Instead, the men turned away. Something in their manner — a sad acquiescence, so easily accepting of rejection — triggered an old memory. My father, a Korean War combat veteran, routinely went into paroxysms of rage over America’s inexcusable mistreatment of Vietnam veterans.



Once, my father and I were riding our horses when we encountered some “peace” bullies picking on a soldier in uniform. Incensed, I galloped my horse directly into the protesters. Afterward, I was grounded; but my father granted me custody of his treasured Combat Infantryman’s Badge.The memory unleashed that old instinct, to stand up for the soldiers.



I called to the men leaving my office. “Wait!” I said. “I’ll write about you, and what the memorial means to you.”It soon became clear that the unbuilt memorial already radiated power, inspiring my vets to express deep reservoirs of grief, love and pride.My veterans’ excitement turned to angst. Some hated that the memorial — nicknamed The Wall —was set into the Earth. They were upset that the designer, Maya Lin, was an Asian woman. My gang of ex-soldiers turned against the Wall.



After the memorial opened just after Veterans Day 1982, though, my vets were overcome with curiosity. Was the Wall a good thing, or a bad thing? Did it insult the vets, or honor them?None wanted to resolve those questions with a visit to Washington. The emotional risk was too great. Instead, they asked if I would examine the Wall on their behalf. They bought me a plane ticket. They tasked me with placing white roses before the panels containing the names of their dead comrades.



I complied eagerly. I wanted to see this Wall, myself. But I was not prepared for what happened in Washington.I had trouble finding the Vietnam memorial. I wandered the Mall at length, toting my roses and growing steadily grumpier. I was about to give up when I nearly fell into a gorge that turned out to be the memorial.



It was heartbreakingly beautiful. I was drawn in, mesmerized at seeing the real names of real soldiers who died while fighting for our country. Methodically, I began to deposit the roses.I noticed a man standing beside me, entranced as if in prayer. On impulse, I asked if he were a Vietnam veteran. Defensively, he nodded yes. I blurted, “Thank you for serving.” He seemed to hold his breath. Then he lunged forward and hugged me. He stood sobbing in the arms of a stranger.



I, too, began to cry, in gratitude for this man’s sacrifice, and from grief that an entire generation of our fine soldiers had been made to feel so thoroughly unappreciated.



Back at home, I told my vets: “You have to see it.” Eventually, most of them did.When the last surviving veteran from the Vietnam War has died, the Wall — which has become a cultural icon — will remain standing. Future generations will visit, and will be well served by the underlying message: We as a nation honor, love and give thanks to all our service members. No matter the war; no matter the posting; no matter if they faced conflict abroad or at home; or encountered enemies foreign or domestic. We owe them our thanks.

Monday, November 2, 2009

Announcing the Uniform EnCounters GC3 Writing Competition

Hey, everyone! As promised: We have a writing competition!

As I wrote in my last post, have I got a deal for you! This blog's sister site, UniformEnCounters, is hosting a fundraiser/writing competition designed to benefit three good causes (GC3): wounded troops; soldier morale; and you, the writer. Here's what you do.

Contest Rules

1. In 700 words or less, write an essay, story, or poem depicting a servicemember or members of the U.S. Armed Forces or their allies (i.e., Australia, Canada, etc.)

2. The subject matter can be any active duty scenario from World War I through the present.

3. Submit your entry in the body of an email to Uniformencounters@gmail.com. In the subject header, use your last name and a slash for category. Example: Obama/Poetry. If you enter more than once in a category, simply add a number in your header (Obama2/Poetry).

4. Submit a $15 entry fee through the UniformEncounters blogsite.

5. Your entry fees will go toward the purchase of voice-activated laptops for wounded troops, in the form of a donation to a remarkably worthy cause, Project Valour-IT.

6. Winning entries will be selected in each of three categories: Fiction, Nonfiction, and Poetry. Winning entrants will receive $50 each, plus publication on the UniformEnCounters site. Runners-up will receive prizes TBD.

7. Entries must be submitted by 8 a.m. EST on 1 December, 2009. Winners will be announced on the UniformEnCounters site on New Year's Day.

Tips and insights: There are no subject rules, but keep in mind that UniformEnCounters exists to raise support for our men and women in uniform. Enter as often as you like, but each entry must be accompanied by its own fee/donation. Fees are processed through PayPal. If you wish to use another method, please email uniformencounters@gmail.com for instructions on how to submit via snail mail.

Thank you in advance to everyone, and in particular to my intrepid squad of reader-volunteers! So now it's time to start writing. GC3 awaits!

The fine print: You retain all rights to your composition/s. By entering the competition, you agree to allow your winning submission to be published on the UniformEnCounters site.

Friday, October 30, 2009

Announcement Forthcoming: A Call to Pen (& Keyboard)


Do you like to write? (doesn't everyone?) Okay, let me rephrase that. Will you write for a good cause? How about a mix of good causes involving wounded troops, veteran/soldier morale, and personal reward? If so: Have I got a deal for you! Stay tuned for a forthcoming announcement on GC3 (Good Causes x 3), and how YOU, O Reader, can participate. Meanwhile, put yourself into writer mode; think GC3; and check back soon for full details.

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Another Reason I Worry About Soldier Injuries


... in addition to all the standard threats:


We put a whole lot of weight on their bodies.


Nominated for Best Online Magazine in Mashable's Open Web Awards

Aw, shucks... and many thanks to pals Phyllis and WOTN for submitting this blog for the annual Mashable Open Web awards! Nominations continue through November 15. Submit your pics once per day. Top nominees in each category get sent through to FINALS! First prize is... uh... bragging rights, glory, and a year long contract with Elite Models. Oh, wait; that's another contest. In any case, this is your chance to show the love. Keep clicking for me, and for your other web faves in other categories!

The Army: It's Not Just About the Rifles. Also Fighting Domestic Violence

Maybe, just maybe, the Marines really do have the best commercials. But the Army is front-runner when it comes to shining a light on social issues. Now, in recognition of Domestic Violence Awareness Month, the Big Green Publicity Machine (AKA Army Public Affairs)has sent out a blurb about a brave civilian, Carolyn Louise Herring Moore, who endured 10 years of homefront assault behind closed doors. Moore, now happily married to an Army staff sergeant, wrote a play about her struggles to survive and eventually escape an abusive marriage.

The play, "Women Shoptalk While Real Men Wait," will be performed this weekend in Fayetteville, NC. The performance is Saturday, October 31.The mil-blurb (linked above) quotes Moore giving advice to people currently entrapped by abuse: "Find help and shelter. Find and seek a purpose. Once you do, you’ll find life after abuse.”

Writes Army journo Pfc. Victor J. Ayala: Since the play was first produced, Moore has been spreading her message of life after abuse to countless audiences, selling out shows and helping others through their own struggles with domestic violence.

That's the Army, my friends. It's not just about the rifles.

Friday, October 23, 2009

Memo to USA Today: Rethink the Headline; Keep the Article

Okay, so this was a really unfortunate title for an article, but the text is worth reading. Not everyone comes out of combat with a raging case of PTSD.

Tuesday, October 20, 2009

Dear Paramount Pictures: I Won't Bill You for Promoting Your FIlms on My Blog

It appears that by posting a video clip in order to illustrate a point, I have angered the perfumed, manicured juris doctor dudes at Paramount. Never mind that the "Broken Arrow" clip (deactivated below) would prompt readers to dash out and purchase the full version of the important film, We Were Soldiers, from whence it was excerpted. The posted clip is a copyright violation, dadblastit! ("A blogger has violated our perimeter! Quick, Reginald! BROKEN ARROW!")

At least I have helped dear Reginald briefly justify his existence (the clip is down, Redge; you can go back now to snorting caviar). And I encourage everyone to carve out a few hours to watch We Were Soldiers, a kick-A film based on a book by my good pal Joe Galloway, one of the coolest people I know. If you haven't seen it yet, here is but a taste. I won't send Paramount a bill for promotional services, seeings how I post this of my own free will.

Tuesday, October 13, 2009

Slaughter at FOB Keating

Still following up on this month's slaughter of American troops at Camp Keating...

Even civilians, who don't often rally to the tick-tock of the war, are so troubled by the incident at Camp Keating that they continue to ask how this happened. How was an entire American military encampment so vulnerable to attack that it was overrun by literally scores of enemy combatants? How did our troops end up - again - in a Broken Arrow situation?

You can point to a problem with Lessons Learned.

In answer to reader Phyllis' query, below, Concrete Bob pointed to lessons we should have learned the hard way:

When enemy combatants are dressed the same as LIP's (Land Indeginous Personnel/Local Indeginous People), when they use mosques to shield their activities, and when they have no compunction about using and/or murdering civilians to further their efforts. They know our military is prohibited from engaging if civilians are present. I would not be surprised to learn they have acquired TAC COMM capabilities and can hear what our guys are saying. Does any of this sound familiar? Haven't we been through a similar situation before? Didn't we learn anything from Viet Nam? The only difference I see is terrain and climate.

We also should have learned lessons that were passed down to us through a long line of warrior-sages.

The great ancient Chinese military theorist Sun Tzu wrote in his treatise, The Art of War:

When in difficult country, do not encamp. Also: Do not linger in dangerously isolated positions.

And yet, our men whose leaders presumably can quote Sun Tzu (and Clausewitz, etc.) in their sleep, were placed inside a base so vulnerable that soldiers referred to the area leading into Camp Keating as "Ambush Alley."

As reported in Chandler's Watch:

When a reporter visited the base a few months after it opened, soldiers stationed in Kamdesh complained the base’s location low in a valley made most missions in the area difficult.
“We’re primarily sitting ducks,” said one soldier at the time.


Known as Camp Keating, the outpost was “not meant for engagements,” said one senior State Department official assigned to Afghanistan, and brings “a sad and terrible conclusion” to a three-year effort to secure roads and connect the Nuristan province to the central government in Kabul.


You also can point to a failure of intelligence, including the failure to plan. I wrote about this two years ago, when I faulted former CIA Chief George Tenet for allowing our HUMINT networks to founder. In a 2007 commentary for the D.C. Examiner, I wrote, in part:

In 1985, when Tenet joined the staff on the powerful Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, the United States deployed a multitude of clandestine agents in the ongoing Cold War against communism. Tenet saw how the brave covert warriors risked and sometimes sacrificed their lives while keeping the Soviet Bloc at bay. He also saw how their work paid off.

In the late 1980s, the Cold War presented a seemingly lesser threat. The intelligence overseers — Tenet included — adopted what can only be described as severe myopia, reading a reduced Soviet threat to mean that we needed fewer covert operations overall.

With little or no HUMINT, our men did not know precisely how many forces were massed in the overlooks on each side of the narrow valley. Nor did they know exactly how the enemy planned to attack in a time and a place of our choosing.

So many questions remain unanswered; and I predict that the Slaughter at FOB Keating will be discussed and analyzed for years to come. Lest too much time pass between the attack and its placement as a curriculum item at West Point, I would like to offer a connecting thread of thought. No, Afghanistan is not Vietnam; but certain things do parallel.

Observe the dramarization below, on a prior and well known Broken Arrow incident.

Do we really want this to happen again to our troops?



Sunday, October 11, 2009

Eyewitness Reports From Camp Keating

H/T to Concrete Bob for giving me the heads-up. Phyllis, this one's for you.

Saturday, October 10, 2009

In "Honour" of Canadian Thanksgiving, a Tribute to Maple Leaf Troops

H/T to dear Aunty Brat for calling this to my attention.


Friday, October 9, 2009

Questions About FOB Keating: How Did It Happen?

My buddy Phyllis posted this on my Facebook today. I answered her question in part, but need to hand off the rest to in-country (or recently returned) experts.

Phyllis asked:

You know about these things, Susan, maybe you can explain it to me: How did we get caught off-guard last weekend??? Weren't there patrols or guards???? How did they evacuate a whole village the day before and we didn't know about it? Don't we have spies in the village?And how are they going to fight an enemy who looks exactly like the people they're trying to help????? It's killing me that our people are like sitting ducks! And they're forced to fight with one hand tied behind their backs. Now they want to pull out of those isolated areas & congregate in the populated areas of the country? Even I know how stupid that is, and I'm just a civilian!.........[I posted this to ISAF, too, but I don't think I'll get a response.]

I responded:

Ahhh.... Phyllis.... you are ask such important questions. I can answer one part. Our HUMINT capabilities (human intelligence; i.e., spies) were gutted some years ago under the tenure of (former) CIA chief George Tenet. I wrote about this a while back in the D.C. Examiner. As for the tick-tock of what actually happened last weekend, I am going to put this to my pals on the ground... if their Internet is up...and see if we can get some informed answers. Guys? You out there?

We await enlightenment.

Thursday, October 8, 2009

Update on Fosco the Dog, the Army's Canine Jumpmaster

If you missed the Fosco post, it's not too late to read about the spunky Army canine - now, with an updated eyewitness report! Click on the link, or scroll down until the pic appears.

Appearing on BlogTalk Radio With BG Ed Cardon and Grim

Tune in today for insightful conversation with Brig. Gen. Ed Cardon, Deputy Commandant, U.S. Army Command and General Staff College. This most thoughtful warrior-scholar spoke to me and Grim about stability operations and other matters. My write-up and commentary are in the works; meanwhile, tune in via computer for an ear-opening discussion you don't often hear.

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

The Army Highlights Another Form of Bravery in Recognition of Domestic Violence Awareness Month

Maybe, just maybe, the Marines really do have the best commercials. But the Army is front-runner when it comes to shining a light on social issues. Today, in recognition of Domestic Violence Awareness Month, the Big Green Publicity Machine (AKA Army Public Affairs) sent out a blurb about a brave civilian, Carolyn Louise Herring Moore, who endured 10 years of homefront assault behind closed doors. Moore, now happily married to an Army staff sergeant, wrote a play about her struggles to survive and eventually escape an abusive marriage.

The play, "Women Shoptalk While Real Men Wait," will be performed in Fayetteville, NC, October 31.

The mil-blurb (linked above) quotes Moore giving advice to people currently entrapped by abuse: "Find help and shelter. Find and seek a purpose. Once you do, you’ll find life after abuse.” Writes Army journo Pfc. Victor J. Ayala: Since the play was first produced, Moore has been spreading her message of life after abuse to countless audiences, selling out shows and helping others through their own struggles with domestic violence.

That's the Army, my friends. It's not just about the rifles.

Monday, October 5, 2009

Uniform Encounters: Fosco the Dog Braver Than Blogger

A couple years ago, I arranged to step out of a speeding aircraft at 12,000 feet with a really cute Army guy tied to my back. Talk about a dream date! Okay, so it was an Army P.R. event, and the guy was old enough to be my nephew and was a purely professional parachutist; but, still... my friends were jealous, and that's all that mattered. As things turned out, though, weather forced us to cancel The Outing. I took it as a sign: Don't jump! I didn't even try to reschedule.


U.S. Army 1st Sgt. Chris Lalonde, center, holds his military working dog, Sgt. Maj. Fosco, while jumpmaster Kirby Rodriguez deploys his parachute over Ft. Leonard Wood, Mo. Lalonde is with Company D, 701st Military Police Battalion. Members of the Army’s Golden Knights look on. U.S. Army photo by Sgt. Vince Vander Maarel

Now comes little Fosco the Dog, a sergeant major in the Canine Corps. He didn't turn tail. He didn't whimper. Maybe they offered him some really good kibble, or maybe he didn't know what he was getting into, but he did it. He jumped! And he lived to bark about it! All I can say is, Good Boy, Fosco! You are a braver creature than I.
**** UPDATE ***
Here is an eyewitness report from lifelong civilian Tessa Long, who blogs about the Army:
Sergeant Major Fosco was...calm as a cucumber. That is, until he touched down and was unstrapped. Then the dog took off running towards another Soldier and attacked him! Don’t worry; it was all part of the plan. The other Soldier was wearing a padded training arm for the dog to bite. Good thing, because SGM Fosco did not let go! “You’d better not throw me out of an airplane again!” I heard someone in the audience say as the dog hung on the training arm. But I don’t think SGM Fosco was angry. As soon as he was told to let go, he let his handler hook him onto a leash and trotted obediently away.
Yip, yip! I want to meet this dog!

Thursday, September 24, 2009

Ahmadinejad Nights: If You Encountered The Thug of Tehran in a Dark Alley...


Good Lord. Does this man give you the willies, or what? Flee, O innocents. Flee!


Monday, September 21, 2009

10 Things You Never Say to Someone With PTSD

As my nearest and dearest know, I have been working on a special project related to my Dad's struggles with PTSD from the Korean War. In the course of this work, I have interviewed scores of PTSD-afflicted veterans, as well as family members, leading research scientists, and in-the-trenches mental health workers. The project is not complete. At some point in the near future, PG, I'll have a wrap. Meanwhile, I've compiled this list of no-goes that actually have been said to soldiers and veterans with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder.

10 Things You Never Say to Someone With PTSD

1. Give it time. It will go away.
No, actually; it won't. A stress reaction goes away. A bad mood goes away. But when trauma-induced stress takes on a life of its own and interferes with human functioning, it won't get better without treatment. That's why the mental health community recognizes PTSD as a genuine, difficult, and potentially debilitating syndrome. Who are you to dismiss this vast body of knowledge?

2. It can't really be that bad.
You wouldn't say this to a grieving widow. You wouldn't say it to someone trapped inside a wrecked car. Do not say it to a soldier/veteran with PTSD. Ever.

3. Shake it off!
Great idea. You go first: shake off your ignorance.

4. My dad's / brother's / cousin's friend knew a guy with PTSD, and he killed himself.
And now his ghost is coming after you, before you tip someone over the edge.

5. You must have done something really bad over there.
The only thing worse than saying this is to probe for details of the "crime." If you are this insensitive, you should not be allowed anywhere near a soldier or veteran.

6. BOO!
Ummm... it is generally a bad idea to try to trigger someone who is struggling with triggers.

7. This proves we shouldn't be in Iraq, Afghanistan, etcetera.
The only thing PTSD proves is that PTSD exists. Don't use individual trauma as a platform for your political beliefs.

8. You bastard. What are you doing to us?
The person who said this knows who she is. I will give her the benefit of the doubt, and assume that she, too, was traumatized by things beyond her control. But, still: when you feel the urge to lash out at someone who is clearly slipping down the drain, it's best to bite your tongue.

9. You should sue.
Who? The Taliban? The Roman Empire? God?

10. It's all in your head.
So is your insensitivity. That doesn't mean it's not real.

(With a nod to my good pal J.P. Borda, whose Golden Rules of Care Packages inspired me to make my own list)

Friday, September 18, 2009

On Rosh Hashana: As Goes Israel, So Goes Western Society

One of my favorite thinkers, Phyllis Chesler, has posted keen observations for Rosh Hashana. Israel's destiny represents the destiny of Western civilization and that of civilized humanity everywhere. Take it to heart.

Thursday, September 17, 2009

Medal of Honor for SFC Jared Monti, Who Gave His Life in Afghanistan

the Medal of Honor is reserved for special troops who risk their lives above and beyond the call of duty. Sadly, the risk is sometimes overwhelming. Today President Obama presents a Medal of Honor to the parents of a man who risked - and gave - his life while trying to save a comrade. A moment of silence, please, for Sergeant First Class Jared Monti, who gave his life in Afghanistan.